Books

Possession Island by Sarah McCarry Book Review

Sharing is caring!

Possession Island by Sarah McCarry is a thrilling book when Angela returns home and the next day her ex-best friend is murdered.

Angela returns to her hometown to visit her father during a break from college and the next day her ex-best friend is brutally murdered. Teaming up with a woman she was barely friends with in high school, Sally, they try to figure out who is the murderer. As time goes on the police are convinced Angela did it. Full of twists and turns, Possession Island will keep you intrigued.

Don’t forget to follow my Bookstagram to stay updated on all my reading: https://www.instagram.com/kels.reading/

Disclaimer: In the name of full transparency, please be aware that this blog post contains affiliate links and any purchases made through such links will result in a small commission for me (at no extra cost to you).

Possession Island

Possession Island Overview

Title: Possession Island

Author: Sarah McCarry

Pages: 320 Pages

Publish Date: December 1st, 2026

Genre: Thrillers

My Star Rating: 4/5 stars! (I loved this book and would recommend it to everyone!)

Grab Your Copy Here: https://link.amazon/B06snRgic

Bookshelf

Synopsis From Amazon

It wasn’t easy for Angela Bell growing up on Possession Island, the remote Pacific Northwest setting of her late mother’s wildly popular vampire novel. When she returns home from college and her estranged best friend, Mo, is murdered, she’s forced to reckon with yet another loss―and finds herself in the crosshairs of the bungled police investigation.

Sally Raleigh has longed to leave the island for years, but she’s trapped by her father’s declining health and her devotion to her charismatic twin brother Adrian. The last thing she needs is her high-school nemesis Angela back in town. But Sally is also devastated by Mo’s death, and finds herself forging an unlikely alliance with her former enemy to find Mo’s killer.

As Angie and Sally delve deeper into the island’s sinister underbelly, they must confront just how far they’re willing to go to protect the people they love. And they’ll soon find that the secrets they’ve been keeping from each other won’t stay buried for long…

My Review of Possession Island

First, thank you to Sarah McCarry, NetGalley, and St. Martin’s Press- Saturday Books for an advance reading copy of Possession Island in exchange for my honest review.

Possession Island lured me in with its promise of vampires, murder mystery, gothic vibes, and lesbians. Sarah McCarry really set the scene in this book and wrote some great characters. They were all suspects in the crime, in my head, at one point or another. I really liked the multiple POVs and the tangled web of relationships between the characters.

I was very intrigued by the relationship between Sally and Angela. They had two completely different experiences in life but ended up in the same place. Angela’s mom wrote a vampire novel and disappeared, leaving her with a huge inheritance. Sally’s dad owns a bar and is slowly losing his memory to dementia. They both struggle with not trusting the men in their lives and trying to find out who killed Mo. I really liked the way their characters developed throughout the book.

The twist and major reveal were kind of a letdown. I’m usually a big fan of a big twist, but this seemed too far-fetched and not plausible. I just don’t understand the motivation and wanted more. Overall, this book is interesting with its premise, and it had so much promise; it kept my attention and kept me wanting more, but I just felt like the ending was flat.

Possession Island

More Thriller Books

Final Thoughts

Possession Island is a wild ride and a very interesting read. The ending fell flat for me but you might enjoy it. If you have any questions about this book or read it and want to talk about it, let me know in the comments below. I love hearing from all of you.

Lastly, if you enjoy these reviews, please share it on your social media. I appreciate all the love and support.

Thanks for reading,

Kel

Possession Island

Sharing is caring!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *